Classic Car Insurance (May 2026)
$200–$600/year typical. Hagerty from $284. Agreed-value coverage pays the full pre-agreed amount on total loss. The mileage trap, vehicle eligibility rules, and how to lock in the right value.
Standard auto insurance is wrong for classics
Standard auto pays Actual Cash Value (ACV) at claim time — depreciated value, not what the car is actually worth. For appreciating classics, ACV is a disaster. Classic insurance pays Agreed Value: the exact pre-agreed amount you and the insurer set on day one. The premium is also typically much lower than standard auto due to the limited mileage and secondary-use profile.
Quick Answer
- Cheapest typical premium: Hagerty from $284/year. Industry range $200–$600/year.
- Best for unlimited pleasure mileage: Grundy — no mileage cap on pleasure or club use.
- Best for modern collectibles (under 25 yrs):American Modern or Hagerty's Modern Collector tier.
- Best for $250K+ vehicles: Chubb (premium-tier HNW) — tailored coverage and white-glove claim service.
- Standard mileage caps: 1,000–7,500/year (most policies set 2,500). Over-mileage claims can be denied.
- Eligibility: 25+ year vehicle + 25+ year-old policyholder + clean record + locked garage + maintained daily driver.
- Coverage: Agreed Value (pre-agreed payout). Re-establish value annually for appreciating cars.
Top Classic Car Carriers Compared
| Feature | Hagerty | Grundy | American Modern | Chubb (HNW) | Safeco |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starting premium | From $284/yrBest | Custom quote | From ~$300/yr | Premium-tier (HNW) | Starts ~$250/yr |
| Annual mileage cap | Up to 7,500 | Unlimited (pleasure)Best | Up to 6,000 | Tailored / unlimited | Up to 5,000 |
| Agreed value | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Vehicle age requirement | 25+ years (typical) — exceptions for newer collectibles | 20+ years | 25+ years | Curated underwriting | 25+ years |
| Best for | Most popular — strong digital flow, valuation tool, magazine + community | Drivers who want unlimited pleasure mileage | Lower-mileage daily-storage owners | Six-figure+ collector vehicles, multi-car collections | Modern collectibles + low-mileage cars |
Vehicle Eligibility Matrix
| Vehicle type | Typical eligibility | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Antique (45+ years old) | Yes — broadest coverage | Pre-1981 vehicles. Standard antique tariff in most carriers. |
| Classic (25–44 years old) | Yes — standard product | 1982–2001 vehicles in 2026. Most common classic-policy use case. |
| Modern collectible (under 25 years) | Limited — case-by-case | Limited-production sports cars, supercars, exotic SUVs. Hagerty Modern Collector available. |
| Restored / restomod | Yes — agreed value | Restoration receipts establish agreed value. Document everything. |
| Custom / kit car | Yes (specialty) | Grundy and American Collectors specialize. Hagerty case-by-case. |
| Original-condition driver-quality car | Yes — most common | Daily-driver quality classics. Lower agreed-value tier than concours-restored. |
| Concours / show-quality | Yes — premium tier | Higher premiums. Photographs + documentation required to establish value. |
Standard vs Classic Insurance — When Each Applies
Classic insurance wins when…
- Vehicle is 25+ years old AND not your daily driver
- Mileage stays under 7,500/year (or you choose Grundy unlimited)
- Car appreciates or holds value over time
- You want agreed value vs depreciated ACV at claim time
- Vehicle is stored in a locked garage
Stay on standard auto when…
- It's your daily driver
- Annual mileage exceeds 7,500
- You don't have garage storage
- Car is depreciating commodity (most modern cars under 20 years)
- You don't maintain a separate daily-driver vehicle
Which classic insurer should you pick?
Match your situation:
- First-time classic owner, daily-quality 1970s-90s car→ Hagerty (from $284/yr)Default choice. Best digital flow + valuation tool + community benefits. Strong claim experience.
- Active driver, attend tours / shows / cruise events→ Grundy (unlimited pleasure mileage)Hagerty's 7,500 mile cap may be tight; Grundy removes mileage tracking entirely for pleasure use.
- Modern collectible (10-25 years old, sports car)→ American Modern OR Hagerty Modern CollectorBoth write modern collectibles. American Modern often cheaper; Hagerty stronger on community + valuation tools.
- Vehicle worth $250,000+→ Chubb or AIG Private ClientHNW carriers have dedicated claim teams, agreed-value increases automatically, white-glove service.
- Multi-car collection (3+ vehicles)→ Hagerty multi-car policy or ChubbMulti-car discounts of 5-15% across both. Single underwriting relationship simpler than per-vehicle policies.
- Custom / kit car / restomod→ Grundy or American CollectorsSpecialty carriers more flexible on non-standard vehicles. Hagerty case-by-case.
- Concours / show-quality / award winner→ Photo-documented Hagerty agreed value at top tierPremium tier reflects show-condition value. Annual photo + appraisal updates lock in appreciation.
Get a Hagerty Classic Car Quote
Hagerty is the largest US classic car insurance specialist with the strongest digital experience and valuation tools. Premiums start at $284/year with agreed-value coverage and Hagerty Drivers Club benefits.
Get a QuoteSponsored partner
Frequently Asked Questions
How we verified this
Pricing data verified May 2026 against CNBC Select's 2026 best classic car insurance review (Hagerty from $284), MoneyGeek 2026 best classic + collector car analysis, NerdWallet 2026 classic insurance guide, ValuePenguin 2026 classic insurance comparison, and Compare.com 2026 coverage guide. Carrier-specific eligibility and mileage rules cross-referenced against Hagerty, Grundy, and American Modern carrier disclosures. Modern collectible eligibility per industry-standard 25-year classic threshold.