FHA vs Conventional vs VA vs USDA (May 2026)
The four major mortgage loan types each fit a specific borrower profile. We compared eligibility, costs, mortgage insurance, and long-term implications so you can map your credit score, down payment, and military status to the right program.
Quick Answer: Which loan type fits you?
- Eligible military / veteran: VA โ 0% down, no monthly MI, almost always cheapest.
- FICO 700+ with 5-20% down: Conventional โ PMI cancels at 78% LTV, lowest long-term cost.
- FICO 580-680 with 3.5%+ down: FHA โ most accessible, but plan to refinance to conventional in 3-5 years.
- Buying in USDA-eligible area + income under 115% AMI: USDA โ 0% down, lower MI than FHA.
- FICO 700+ with 3% down: Conventional 97 LTV (HomeReady/Home Possible) โ beats FHA long-term.
- Self-employed / complex income: Conventional โ more underwriting flexibility than FHA.
- Investment property or second home: Conventional โ others are primary residence only.
FHA MIP gotcha โ lasts LIFE of loan if <10% down
The single biggest cost trap in FHA loans: with the typical 3.5% down payment, MIP (0.55% annually) lasts the entire life of the loan. To escape it, you must refinance to a conventional loan once you reach 20% equity. On a $350K loan, that's ~$160/month for 30 years if you don't refinance โ over $50,000 in MIP alone. Conventional PMI cancels automatically at 78% LTV. Plan your FHA loan strategy with a refinance trigger built in.
Mortgage Loan Type Comparison Matrix
| Feature | FHA | Conventional | VA | USDA |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Backed by | Federal Housing Administration (HUD) | Fannie Mae / Freddie Mac (private) | Veterans Affairs | USDA Rural Development |
| Minimum credit score | 580 (with 3.5% down) / 500 (10% down)Best | 620 typical (lower with manual underwriting) | No federal min (lender 620 typical) | 640 most lenders |
| Down payment minimum | 3.5% (with 580+ FICO) | 3% (HomeReady/Home Possible) / 5% standard | 0%Best | 0% |
| Mortgage insurance UPFRONT | 1.75% UFMIP (financed into loan) | NoneBest | VA funding fee 1.25-3.3% (waived for disabled vets) | 1.0% upfront fee (financed) |
| Mortgage insurance ONGOING (annual) | 0.55% MIP for most borrowers | PMI 0.5-1.5%/yr based on credit + LTV | $0 โ noneBest | 0.35%/yr |
| Mortgage insurance CANCELLATION | LASTS LIFE OF LOAN if <10% down; 11 yrs if 10%+ down | Cancels at 78% LTV automatic; can request at 80% | N/A โ no ongoing MIBest | Cancels at 80% LTV |
| Loan limits 2026 (standard county) | $541,287 | $766,550 | No limit (full entitlement)Best | Varies by county, no formal max |
| Loan limits 2026 (high-cost county) | $1,249,125 | $1,149,825 | No limit (full entitlement)Best | Varies |
| Property condition requirements | Strict โ must meet FHA Minimum Property Standards (no lead paint, structural issues, etc.) | Less strict โ appraiser only flags major issuesBest | VA appraisal required, similar standards to FHA | Property must be in USDA-eligible area; condition standards similar to FHA |
| Property type eligibility | Primary residence only; condos must be FHA-approved | Primary, second home, investmentBest | Primary residence only | Primary residence only; rural/suburban areas |
| DTI (debt-to-income) maximum | Up to 50% with compensating factorsBest | 43-50% typical | 41% guideline (often flexible) | 41% guideline |
| Income limits | NoneBest | HomeReady/Home Possible cap at 80% AMI; standard conventional has no cap | None | 115% area median income |
| Best for | FICO 580-680 + low down payment + may need property repairs | FICO 700+ + 5%+ down + property options + cancellable MI | Eligible military/veterans (almost always wins) | Income-eligible buyers in USDA-eligible areas |
10-year cost comparison: $350K home, 3.5% down (FHA-eligible scenario)
Same borrower, same home, three loan types. 720 FICO. 10-year ownership horizon. APRs from May 2026 sample rates.
| Loan Type | Down Payment | Monthly P&I | Monthly MI | 10-Year Total Cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FHA (3.5% down, lifetime MIP) | $12,250 | $2,253 | $157 | $305,250 |
| Conventional 97 (3% down, PMI cancels at year 8) | $10,500 | $2,225 | $200 โ $0 | $291,300 |
| VA (eligible, 0% down) | $0 | $2,348 | $0 | $281,760 |
The take: Over 10 years, VA wins by $9,540 vs Conventional 97 and $23,490 vs FHA โ even though VA borrows the full home price. The compounding savings from no MI ever and 0% down (more cash to invest elsewhere) make VA the clear winner for eligible borrowers. Conventional 97 beats FHA by $13,950 over 10 years because PMI cancels around year 8 while FHA MIP continues. The longer you stay, the bigger the FHA disadvantage grows.
Which loan type should you choose?
Match your profile to the right program:
- Active duty military, veteran, or eligible spouse โ any down payment situationโ VA loan (almost always wins)VA loans are the most generous mortgage product: 0% down, no monthly mortgage insurance, competitive rates, no loan limit for full-entitlement borrowers since 2020. The one-time funding fee (1.25-3.3%, can be financed) replaces years of MI payments. The only reasons to choose another loan type: (a) using VA entitlement on a different property simultaneously, (b) buying investment property (VA is primary residence only), (c) seller refuses to negotiate VA appraisal repair items.
- FICO 700+, 5-20% down available, want lowest long-term costโ Conventional loanConventional wins for prime borrowers with reasonable down payment because: (a) PMI cancels automatically at 78% LTV (vs FHA MIP lasting life of loan with <10% down), (b) PMI rate is competitive with FHA MIP for 700+ FICO borrowers, (c) more property type flexibility (second homes, investment), (d) easier appraisal process. With 20% down, conventional has zero PMI from day one.
- FICO 580-680, less than 5% down availableโ FHA loanFHA is the practical entry point for credit-challenged or low-down-payment first-time buyers. 580 FICO + 3.5% down is the sweet spot. Trade-off: MIP lasts the life of the loan if you start with less than 10% down. Strategy: take the FHA loan now, build equity for 3-5 years, refinance to conventional once you reach 20% equity AND your credit improves. The FHA-then-refi path is often the cheapest legitimate way to enter homeownership for sub-680 FICO borrowers.
- Buying in eligible rural/suburban area, household income under 115% AMIโ USDA loanUSDA Rural Development loans offer 0% down + lower MI than FHA + competitive rates for eligible borrowers. "Rural" per USDA includes many suburban communities โ not just farms. Use eligibility.sc.egov.usda.gov to check a specific property. For income-eligible borrowers in eligible areas, USDA almost always beats FHA on cost and beats conventional on accessibility.
- FICO 700+, only 3% down availableโ Conventional 97% LTV (HomeReady or Home Possible)Fannie Mae HomeReady and Freddie Mac Home Possible programs accept 3% down for first-time buyers with 700+ FICO. The PMI is more expensive monthly than FHA MIP, but cancels automatically once you reach 20% equity (or you can request cancellation at 80% LTV). Over a 5-10 year ownership horizon, conventional 97% with cancellable PMI almost always beats FHA with lifetime MIP for prime credit borrowers. Income limit applies (80% AMI for HomeReady/Home Possible).
- Buying a fixer-upper requiring repairs over $5,000โ FHA 203(k) renovation loanFHA 203(k) finances both home purchase AND renovation costs in a single mortgage. Required when the property doesn't meet FHA's minimum standards in current condition (peeling lead paint, missing systems, structural issues). Standard FHA wouldn't close on a property needing work. Conventional renovation alternative: Fannie Mae HomeStyle Renovation loan, but it requires 700+ FICO and 5% down. For lower-credit buyers needing renovation financing, 203(k) is the only path. Available through specialized lenders like loanDepot.
- Self-employed, complex income, or non-W2 incomeโ Conventional (with experienced loan officer)Conventional underwriting is more flexible with non-W2 income (1099 contractors, K-1 distributions, rental income, schedule C) than FHA. FHA underwriting is more rigid because the federal government is insuring the loan. Self-employed borrowers typically need 2 years of consistent income documentation โ conventional lenders work with this routinely; FHA lenders may require manual underwriting and additional documentation.
- Buying a second home or investment propertyโ Conventional (FHA + VA + USDA all primary-residence only)FHA, VA, and USDA all restrict to primary residences. Buying a second home, vacation property, or rental investment requires conventional financing. Investment property loans typically require 20-25% down and 0.5-0.75 percentage points higher rates than primary residence loans. Second homes can use conventional with 10% down at primary-residence-comparable rates.
When to refinance from FHA to conventional
If you took an FHA loan, plan a refi-to-conventional trigger to escape lifetime MIP. The math:
- โขReach 20% equity โ combination of principal payments + home price appreciation. Often happens around year 4-7 of ownership in normal markets.
- โขImprove your FICO to 680+ โ needed to qualify for competitive conventional rates.
- โขCalculate refi break-even โ closing costs (~$7-15K) divided by monthly MI savings (~$150-250/mo). Break-even typically 3-5 years post-refi.
- โขEnsure you'll stay in the home past break-even โ refi only worthwhile if you keep the loan long enough to recoup costs.
Many borrowers take an FHA loan in years 1-5, then refi to conventional in years 5-10. Total cost of the FHA-then-refi path is often cheaper than 30 years of FHA, but more expensive than starting with conventional 97 LTV if you could have qualified. Run your specific scenario through a refinance calculator before committing.
Track your credit score during the FHA-to-conventional refi window
If you took an FHA loan and plan to refinance to conventional after building equity, you'll need 680+ FICO at refi time. Credit Sesame gives you free credit monitoring so you can track your progress and time the refi for when your credit qualifies for the best conventional rate. $0 to start.
Track My CreditSponsored partner
Frequently Asked Questions
How we built this
Loan program details verified May 2026 against HUD.gov FHA guidelines, va.gov VA Home Loan benefit pages, USDA Rural Development eligibility (eligibility.sc.egov.usda.gov), Fannie Mae HomeReady and Freddie Mac Home Possible product disclosures, and 2026 conforming loan limits from the Federal Housing Finance Agency. FHA MIP rules verified against HUD Mortgagee Letter guidance. VA funding fee schedule verified against current va.gov disclosures.