SoFi vs. Marcus vs. Ally Savings: Which HYSA Wins in 2026?
Three of the most popular high-yield savings accounts compared on APY, fees, minimums, and extras — so you can pick the right one for your money in 2026.
Quick Answer
SoFi, Marcus by Goldman Sachs, and Ally Bank are consistently ranked among the best high-yield savings accounts in 2026. This page compares all three on APY, fee structure, FDIC coverage, customer service, and features like savings buckets and no-penalty CDs, so you can see exactly which account fits your situation.
3-Way Comparison: SoFi vs Marcus vs Ally
| Feature | SoFi | Marcus | Ally |
|---|---|---|---|
| APY | 4.00% APY (w/ direct deposit) | 4.10% APYBest | 4.00% APY |
| APY without direct deposit | 1.20% APY | 4.10% APYBest | 4.00% APY |
| Minimum balance | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Monthly fee | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| FDIC coverage | Up to $2M (via partner banks)Best | $500K per depositor | $250K per depositor |
| Checking account | Yes (bundled) | No | Yes (optional) |
| Mobile app rating | ★★★★★ | ★★★★☆ | ★★★★★ |
| Customer service | Chat / phone | Phone / chat | 24/7 phone and chatBest |
| Savings buckets | No | No | Yes (Ally Buckets)Best |
| No-penalty CD | No | Yes | Yes |
APYs verified against each bank's disclosure page as of June 2026. Rates are subject to change. Your actual rate depends on account type and, for SoFi, whether you have qualifying direct deposit.
What $10,000 Earns in 1 Year
The $10/year difference between Marcus and Ally on a $10,000 balance is negligible. Your decision should come down to features and banking experience, not rate alone.
Find the right high-yield savings account for you
Compare SoFi, Marcus, Ally, and other top HYSAs side-by-side. See current rates, no credit check required.
Sponsored network. WalletGrower may earn a commission when you qualify with one of our partners. Rankings are independent.
Bank-by-bank breakdown
SoFi High-Yield Savings
SoFi pairs a high-yield savings account (4.00% APY for qualified depositors with direct deposit) with a checking account that earns 0.50% APY. For people who want one app for all their banking, SoFi is the strongest option on this list.
Key benefits
- No minimum balance, no monthly fees
- Checking account included in the same app
- Up to $2M FDIC coverage through partner banks
- Member perks: career coaching, financial planning
Watch-outs
- 4.00% APY requires qualifying direct deposit; without it, rate drops to 1.20% APY
- APY trails Marcus by 10 basis points even with direct deposit
Marcus by Goldman Sachs
Marcus offers 4.10% APY for qualified depositors with no conditions, no minimum balance, and no monthly fee. It is a savings-only account — there is no checking account option.
Key benefits
- Highest APY on this list with no strings attached
- No minimum balance, no monthly fee
- Backed by Goldman Sachs, FDIC insured up to $500K
- No-penalty CD available alongside savings
Watch-outs
- No checking account — Marcus cannot be your primary banking app
- You will need a separate checking account elsewhere
Ally Bank Savings
Ally earns 4.00% APY for qualified depositors with no minimum balance and no monthly fee. Its real edge is experience: 24/7 live phone support, a top-rated mobile app, savings buckets for goal tracking, and no-penalty CDs alongside savings.
Key benefits
- 4.00% APY, no minimum, no monthly fee
- Savings buckets for goal tracking without extra accounts
- No-penalty CD available alongside savings
- 24/7 live phone and chat support
- Optional checking account available
Watch-outs
- APY trails Marcus by 10 basis points (0.10%)
- FDIC coverage capped at $250K per depositor (lower than SoFi)
Which HYSA should you choose?
Match your situation to the right account:
- Want the highest guaranteed APY with no conditionsMarcus4.10% APY for qualified depositors with no direct deposit requirement, no minimum, and no monthly fee. Cleanest path to the highest available rate.
- Want banking and savings in one appSoFiBundled checking and savings, 4.00% APY with direct deposit, and up to $2M FDIC coverage. Best for consolidating your banking into one place.
- Want to set up direct deposit and maximize your rateSoFi or MarcusBoth deliver approximately 4% APY for qualified depositors. If you already plan to direct deposit, SoFi adds checking account and extras; Marcus wins on pure APY.
- Want 24/7 phone supportAllyAlly is the only one of the three offering 24/7 live phone and chat support — a meaningful differentiator when you need help fast.
- Want savings buckets or goal trackingAllyAlly Buckets lets you divide one savings account into named sub-accounts. No other bank on this list offers a comparable built-in feature.
- Want a no-penalty CD alongside savingsAlly or MarcusBoth offer no-penalty CDs that let you lock in a rate with the option to withdraw early without a fee. SoFi does not currently offer a no-penalty CD.
Frequently Asked Questions
Know your credit score before opening a new account
Some banks use soft credit checks during account opening. Check your score for free so there are no surprises.
Sponsored partner
More banking resources
Updated June 2026.